Miami News

People want different things: Relationship expectations are all over the place

Why clear communication—not just commitment—is the key to relationship compatibility

No single pattern fits everyone

Most people aren’t looking for the same thing in a relationship. Countless studies show that people differ in what they value, what kind of commitment they want, and what rules they expect partners to follow.

A 2023 study from the University of Toronto looked at 896 adults aged 18 to 65. It asked how they viewed exclusivity, emotional support, and long-term planning. People ranked these values differently. Twenty-nine percent preferred full exclusivity right from the start. Another group (about 19 percent) said they were fine with casual arrangements. The rest were somewhere in between.

So, two people could date for months before realizing their values don’t match. That kind of mismatch causes tension. But it’s not new, and it’s not rare.

Picking paths that don’t match the usual map

Some prefer stable, long-term partnerships. Others seek flexibility, or something less traditional. Open relationships, long-distance set-ups, even agreements between friends—all of these are part of how people shape their lives. What looks unorthodox to one person may feel completely natural to someone else.

In cities where styles vary by the block, choices widen fast. A couple might meet through shared hobbies, co-workers build something quietly, or someone tries something different altogether—like being a sugar daddy in Miami. What counts more than the label is whether both people are clear—and okay—with what they want.

Where problems often begin: Expectations without clarity

Problems don’t always start with bad intentions. They usually come from people not saying what they expect. One study from Northwestern University in 2020 had 314 dating couples record conversations over a two-week period. Partners often assumed the other person wanted the same things. But when the researchers compared the partners’ expectations, only 51 percent of the couples were aligned.

When there's a mismatch, small things feel bigger. For example, someone might think they’re exclusive. But their partner assumes they’re still seeing others. One person might expect daily check-ins while the other sees texts as optional. Misunderstandings are common when no one explains what they mean by “relationship.”

A couple holding hands while walking together in a lush green park, surrounded by trees and sunlight.

Younger people don’t agree on labels

Age matters as well. A nationwide U.S. survey published in The Journal of Sex Research in 2021 asked people in different age groups how they define dating. Participants aged 18 to 22 were less likely to say that dating means exclusivity. Only 38 percent in that group said dating one person implied a committed relationship. Among people aged 35 and older, that number was 71 percent.

What this means is that two people of different ages might use the same word, like "dating," and mean completely different things. That confusion can lead to unmet expectations and frustration.

Motivation comes into play

Another difference is why people enter relationships in the first place. A 2019 publication by researchers from UCLA broke it down into five main motivations: love, companionship, status, security, and physical attraction. Each was rated on a 7-point scale by over 600 participants. Women ranked emotional support higher, on average. Men scored physical attraction slightly higher. But even within gender groups, scores varied widely.

This matters because if one person views a relationship as emotionally central and the other sees it as something fun but casual, they’ll most likely disappoint each other. This doesn’t mean anyone is wrong. It means they’re mismatched.

Non-traditional styles are not outliers

In a study done by Dr. Rhonda Balzarini in 2022, about 23 percent of the 1,200 U.S. adults surveyed said they had been in some form of consensual non-exclusive relationship. These include open arrangements, polyamory, or negotiated flexibility.

The study showed that satisfaction levels were not necessarily lower in these groups. What mattered more was agreement. People in open partnerships reported similar satisfaction levels to those in exclusive ones, as long as both partners agreed to the same terms. So again, clarity mattered more than the structure.

Context shapes wants

Social expectations, peer influence, and local norms all help shape people’s wants. In cities, people might see more examples of non-traditional set-ups than in small towns. A 2020 Pew Research study found that urban residents were more likely to say they are comfortable with different dating models than those in rural areas.

Also, media changes perception. Repeated exposure to different types of partnerships on screen and online can make those options feel more normal. But again, this doesn’t mean those methods work for everyone. What it does is shift what people think is available.

Misalignments are common, not fatal

Disagreements in expectations don’t always mean the end. But they can cause damage if ignored. An analysis of breakups from 150 couples in a 2021 study at the University of Denver found that 61 percent listed unmet relationship goals as one of the reasons for ending things. Most did not describe dramatic problems. They said they simply “weren’t on the same page.”

This suggests that small disconnects build over time. One person starts to feel the relationship isn’t going anywhere. The other may be content where it is. Over time, patience runs out.

People change their minds over time

Wants are not fixed. One study from Temple University followed a group of dating adults for three years. Nearly 40 percent changed how they rated the importance of exclusivity. Life events, mental health changes, work stress, and partner influence shifted what they wanted. People who once wanted open relationships moved toward monogamy. Some went the other way.

So even if two people start off wanting the same thing, they might not stay that way. Regular check-ins can help—but only if both people are ready to listen and speak honestly.

It's not bbout the model. It's about the match.

Many types of partnerships can work. But mismatched expectations tend to lead to disappointment. Open models aren’t always unstable. Monogamy isn’t always safer. What matters more is whether two people agree on their aims, limits, and values. People often assume they understand each other. But studies show they usually don’t unless they make the effort.

Labels help only when they mean the same thing to both people involved. Otherwise, they confuse more than clarify. And sometimes, what one person labels as progress, another might see as pressure.

Being clear and checking in often reduces those chances. But no plan works if expectations stay unspoken.

For more Miami-related news, subscribe to the Calle Ocho News newsletter. Need to advertise your business with our diverse readership? Contact Pressnet Corp. to explore all opportunities!

Stay up to date with the latest news from Miami

Add Comment

Click here to post a comment