Florida lawmakers consider 50% ‘Sin Tax’ as creator Sophie Rain comments on proposal

A viral tax idea, a fierce response from Sophie Rain, and a growing debate over freedom, faith, and Florida’s creator economy

Miami is no stranger to bold political proposals, but one new idea coming out of Florida is sparking heated debate from Little Havana to Tallahassee. A proposed 50% “sin tax” targeting OnlyFans creators living in Florida has ignited backlash online—and now one of the platform’s most recognizable faces is speaking out. In a statement to People, Miami-based creator Sophie Rain didn’t mince words, calling the proposal “the dumbest thing I’ve ever heard of.”

Sophie Rain pushes back on faith, choice, and control

Sophie Rain’s criticism is aimed directly at James Fishback, who has promoted what he calls the “first of its kind” sin tax—arguing that activity on OnlyFans should be taxed at 50% because it represents “sin.” Rain, who identifies as Christian and is the founder of the Bop House, rejected that framing outright.

She emphasized that her decision to join OnlyFans was her own and questioned how a tax based on moral judgment could even be defined or enforced. “I don’t need a 31-year-old man telling me I can’t sell my body online,” Rain said, adding that her faith is personal and not subject to political approval. She also noted that the proposal targets creators—not subscribers—something she says makes little sense.

What the proposal could mean for Florida—and Miami

Beyond the viral back-and-forth, the proposal raises serious questions for Florida’s economy. South Florida, including Miami-Dade and Coral Gables, has become a major hub for digital creators. Rain warned that singling out OnlyFans earners could push creators—and their income—out of the state.

She also suggested the bill could face constitutional challenges and predicted it would fail once it reaches the Senate floor. As Miami continues to position itself as a home for entrepreneurs, influencers, and creative workers, debates like this highlight the tension between regulation, morality, and economic reality.

For ongoing coverage of Florida lawmakers, Miami events, and the issues shaping our community, subscribe to the Calle Ocho News newsletter. And if you’re a local business or agency looking to reach engaged South Florida audiences, contact Pressnet Corp. to explore advertising opportunities with Calle Ocho News.